Federal Lawsuit Against SF City Attorney Dismissed by U.S. News and World Report

San Francisco City Attorney David Chiu has revealed troubling practices behind U.S. News and World Report’s “Best Hospitals” rankings. It was confirmed that the company accepted payments to include hospitals on the list, according to U.S. District Attorney Ismail J. Ramsey.

Chiu raised concerns about the methodology used by U.S. News in determining the rankings, stating that the company did not consider financial factors and may have violated California laws. He pointed out that the rankings could skew funding towards specialty hospitals, potentially leading to the closure of community and safety-net hospitals.

Furthermore, Chiu accused U.S. News of not disclosing payments received from the hospitals it ranks, which he believes violates FTC regulations. The company allegedly receives payments through licensing fees, subscriptions for data access, and page advertisements.

In response to Chiu’s concerns, several law schools, medical schools, and colleges have withdrawn from the rankings. Despite the backlash, U.S. News refused to address the issues raised by the City Attorney and filed a lawsuit against him, claiming violations of their First Amendment rights.

However, prosecutors denied U.S. News’ motion for a preliminary injunction and granted Chiu’s motion to dismiss the lawsuit. Chiu emphasized that U.S. News is not above the law and expressed disappointment in the company’s attempt to evade legitimate questions about its financial ties to ranked hospitals.

As a result, U.S. News is ordered to pay Chiu for fees and costs incurred during the legal proceedings. The case sheds light on the importance of transparency and integrity in ranking systems, especially in critical sectors like healthcare.