Louisiana’s controversial bill to help parents afford private school tuition has cleared a major hurdle in the state Legislature, sparking debate over accountability and cost. The House passed Senate Bill 313, which establishes education savings accounts for parents to use state tax dollars for private school expenses. However, questions remain about the program’s cost and oversight of private schools receiving public funds.
The bill, supported by Republicans and opposed by Democrats, now awaits Senate approval of House amendments before heading to Gov. Jeff Landry. Critics argue the bill lacks accountability measures for private schools and could divert public money without ensuring student performance standards.
State Rep. Larry Bagley proposed grading private schools based on student test scores to hold them accountable, but the amendment was rejected. Rep. Julie Emerson, a bill author, defended the legislation’s safeguards, requiring private schools to administer tests and report scores to the state.
The bill’s evolution from an earlier version with set grant amounts and eligibility criteria reflects concerns over potential costs exceeding $500 million annually. The revised bill leaves grant amounts and timelines to the state Board of Elementary and Secondary Education, prompting uncertainty about the program’s financial impact.
Despite assurances from Landry that all families will eventually qualify for tuition grants, the program’s expansion will depend on funding availability and board decisions. Lawmakers stress the need for flexibility in implementing the program based on financial constraints.
As Louisiana navigates the complexities of funding private education, the future of the bill hinges on balancing accessibility with accountability in the state’s education system.