The age-old debate of keyboard and mouse vs gamepad continues to divide gamers, with each side presenting compelling arguments for their preferred input method. At Tom’s Guide, the editorial team is no exception, with members holding strong opinions on the matter.
For Senior Staff Writer Tony Polanco, a self-proclaimed console gamer, the gamepad reigns supreme. With a collection of gaming controllers spanning generations, Polanco believes that games are meant to be played with a controller, not a mouse and keyboard. While he appreciates the precision and accuracy offered by gaming peripherals, his preferred genres like action-adventure and racing games are best enjoyed with a gamepad.
On the other hand, AI editor Ryan Morrison has a deep-rooted love for keyboard-based gaming. From playing Civilization on his Amiga 600 to mastering the WASD keys in modern games like Fortnite, Morrison finds the precision of a keyboard and mouse more satisfying and manageable than a controller.
Managing Editor Jason England, while acknowledging the advantages of a keyboard and mouse for certain genres, ultimately prefers the versatility of a gamepad across different types of games. He values the freedom of playing from the comfort of his sofa without being tethered to a desk.
Senior Editor Anthony Spadafora highlights the evolving landscape of gaming input methods, noting that keyboards are no longer limited to PCs. With the rise of cross-platform compatibility, players can now enjoy the benefits of a keyboard and mouse on consoles like the PS5 and Xbox Series X.
As the debate rages on, one thing is clear – there is no one-size-fits-all answer. Whether you prefer the precision of a mouse and keyboard or the comfort of a gamepad, the choice ultimately comes down to personal preference. And in the diverse world of gaming, there’s room for all types of players to find their perfect input method.