Will Summer Lee’s Criticism of Israel Impact Her Chances in the PA House Primary?

In a highly anticipated primary race in Pennsylvania’s 12th District, Congresswoman Summer Lee, a member of the left-wing “Squad” in Washington, is facing off against challenger Bhavini Patel. Two years ago, Lee barely won her primary campaign, but now she is the dominant front-runner, backed by the party establishment despite her controversial criticism of Israel.

The primary has become a major test of party attitudes towards the Middle East, especially in the wake of the recent conflict between Hamas and Israel. Lee, known for her vocal criticism of Israel, has garnered support from mainstream party leaders, labor unions, and left-wing lawmakers like Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez.

While Lee’s stance on the Gaza war has impressed some voters, it has also alienated Jewish constituents in the district, particularly in Squirrel Hill, the heart of Pittsburgh’s Jewish community. Some voters feel that Lee’s position on Israel is too extreme, while others appreciate her commitment to her convictions.

The primary falls during Passover, and efforts are being made to encourage observant Jewish voters to cast their ballots. The race has energized and activated a group within the Jewish community, with some voters switching party affiliations to participate in the primary.

As the election approaches, the outcome remains uncertain, with voters like Kate Borger feeling torn between supporting Lee’s progressive policies and concerns about her stance on Israel. The primary will test the balance between progressive values and support for traditional party positions in a district deeply divided on these issues.